State v. Williams
About the Case
In State v. Williams, the Commission conducted a hearing on June 4-7, 2019 for two cases related to two different convictions for claimant Merritt Williams, State vs. Merritt Williams Drayton (Forsyth – 86 CRS 018809 – Wilson) and State vs. Merritt Williams Drayton (Forsyth – 86 CRS 031738 – Bryson).
The Commission concluded in that there was sufficient evidence of factual innocence to merit judicial review in State vs. Merritt Williams Drayton (86 CRS 031738 – Bryson). This case was referred forward for a hearing before a three-judge panel. Please contact the Forsyth County Clerk of Court regarding information about the three judge panel.
The Commission concluded that there was not sufficient evidence of factual innocence to merit judicial review in State vs. Merritt Williams Drayton (86 CRS 018809 – Wilson).
The documents presented at the Commission hearing became public record and are included here. The court sealed some documents from the public record and also ruled that certain photos would not be published on the Commission’s website. Those photos are available at the Forsyth County Clerk’s office. In addition, the Commission’s Alternate Chair ruled that though the Wilson case closed, because the Bryson case moved forward, all documents considered by the Commission at the hearing would be made public at the Bryson case.
The transcript of the Commission hearing is available for viewing ONLY. If you would like to purchase a printed copy of the hearing transcript, please contact Tori Pittman at (919) 931-6222 or pittsteno@protonmail.com
Resources
State v. Merritt Williams Drayton Commission Brief
State v. Merritt Williams Drayton Hearing Transcript Vol 1
State v. Merritt Williams Drayton Hearing Transcript Vol 2
State v. Merritt Williams Drayton Hearing Transcript Vol 3
State v. Merritt Williams Drayton Hearing Transcript Vol 4
State v. Merritt Williams Drayton Hearing PowerPoint Presentation
State v. Merritt Williams Drayton Commission Hearing Handouts
Video Clip 1 – Deposition with Robbin Carmichael
Video Clip 2 – Deposition with Robbin Carmichael
Video Clip 3 – Deposition with Robbin Carmichael
Item Sealed by Order of the Court – Video of WSPD Interview with Robbin Carmichael
Audio Clip – Interview with Darren Johnson
Item Sealed by Order of the Court – Video of WSPD Interview with Darren Johnson
Video Clip 1 – Portion of Mattie Mae Davis Deposition
Video Clip 2 – Portion of Mattie Mae Davis Deposition
Video Clip 3 – Portion of Mattie Mae Davis Deposition
State v. Merritt Williams Drayton (Bryson) Opinion
State v. Merritt Williams Drayton (Wilson) Opinion